The Marketing Decision Matrix: How BPMs Can Choose the Right Path to Offer Digital Marketing Services

For BPMs, CRM providers, and platform companies, the pressure to deliver digital marketing services to small business customers is rapidly increasing.

SMBs are looking for more than just tools - they want real marketing results. They're asking for help with SEO, social media, email marketing, paid advertising, and reputation management. They want more visibility, more leads, and ultimately more sales.

The demand is clear, but meeting it isn't that easy. Your clients often don't have the time, money, or in-house expertise to manage marketing themselves, so they look to you for solutions. Meanwhile, competitors are stepping up with their own marketing offerings, putting your customer relationships (and your long-term growth) at risk.

You know that adding marketing services could unlock significant revenue opportunities and make your platform more sustainable, but there's one big question: How do you actually do it?

You have four main options, each with its own set of trade-offs:

→ Build it yourself
→ Buy an existing solution
→ Integrate with third-party tools
→ Or partner with AgencyEngine

Choosing the right path isn't easy — and the wrong decision could cost you years of effort, millions of dollars, or your competitive edge. That's why we've written this guide. In the following sections, we'll break down each of these options in detail, looking at the pros, cons and key considerations to help you decide what's best for your business.

The Four Options in the Marketing Decision Matrix: How They Stack Up

Option 1: Build — Total Control, Total Commitment

Building your own marketing solution from scratch is the most obvious and ambitious approach. When you build in-house, you get full control: you own the IP, control the roadmap and customize every feature to your vision.

Sounds great, right? And it can be, but only if you have the budget, time, and talent to pull it off. Jeff Bezos used the phrase "focus on what makes your beer taste better" as a way of explaining the benefits of outsourcing non-core functions to experts, like AWS.

Building is expensive. We’re talking about millions of dollars over multiple years - not just for initial development, but for ongoing maintenance, hiring specialized marketing tech talent, customer support, compliance, security, and continuous innovation.

Even in a best-case scenario, a company could spend 12 - 24 months and a lot of money to launch - and that's assuming everything goes according to plan. On the other hand, a missed deadline or shifting product priorities could extend that timeline indefinitely.

Additionally, every hour your product and engineering teams spend building a marketing platform is an hour they’re not spending on your core product. Therefore, if you don't have the runway and willingness to make a long term investment, building your own solution could end up costing you more than it's worth.

Countless once‑promising products now sit in the graveyard of failed launches, many of them martech tools that were simply built the wrong way. If you decide to invest, first dig into the unique complexities of small‑business digital marketing (see our guide) and be absolutely certain your team can deliver a solution that succeeds in the real world.

Questions to Ask Before Building:

• Can we really afford to wait 1-2 years to launch this?
  
  
• Is owning 100% of the solution worth the massive upfront of several M$?
  
  
• Do I want to keep investing in it over time as the market evolves?

• Do I have the expertise to build it right?

Ready to Elevate Your CRM Experience?

Discover how AgencyEngine combines AI website builder technology, marketing automation, and local SEO capabilities into one integrated marketing platform.

Option 2: Partner With a Marketing Agency — Quick Expertise, Limited Control

For a CRM company that wants to add marketing‑services revenue without building a new team from scratch, partnering with an established digital‑marketing agency can feel like the fastest path forward.

Overnight, you inherit seasoned strategists, campaign managers, copywriters, and designers who can serve your merchant base under your brand (white‑label) or as a named partner.

But that speed comes with trade‑offs:

Thin margins:  Once the agency’s service fees are paid, there’s often little profit left for you—especially on smaller merchant accounts.

Slow time‑to‑value:  Campaigns rely on human specialists to plan, launch, and optimize, so merchants may wait weeks (or longer) before they see tangible results.

Reputational risk:  Any typo, compliance slip, or missed deadline by the agency carries your brand name, putting your company’s credibility on the line for mistakes you didn’t make.

Key Questions Before You Sign:

• Margin math: After the agency’s fees, what profit—if any—do we clear per merchant?

• Time‑to‑value: What launch timeline and performance milestones can the agency commit to, and how are they enforced? Will my users be delighted if they wait over 30 days to get their new website?

• Brand protection: What quality‑control and compliance processes guard against errors that could damage our reputation?

Partnering can plug an immediate gap in expertise, but be sure the convenience today won’t translate into loss of control—and profit—tomorrow.

Option 3: Integrate — Fast, But Fragmented

Integrating multiple third-party marketing tools is the quickest way to offer some marketing capabilities without building or buying a full platform.

This approach allows you to use the best tools for things like email marketing, SEO or paid advertising - however, it can result in a patchwork experience for your customers.

Different tools often mean different logins, inconsistent branding, and a fragmented user journey. Imagine a small business owner trying to launch a campaign: they log into one tool to create an email, another to track leads, and yet another to manage their online reviews - each with its own interface, workflow, and billing system. It’s disjointed, confusing, and creates friction at every step.

You can see how many tools it takes to match all of AgencyEngine's features in under 'AI-Driven Opportunities for SMB Website Builders' in our recent post.

In theory, you’re offering a full marketing stack. In practice, your users may feel like they’re piecing it together themselves, which undermines the value and simplicity they’re expecting from your platform.

So If your goal is to provide a cohesive, branded, and revenue-generating marketing experience, integration alone often falls short.

It may be fast and flexible upfront, but it rarely delivers the seamless experience clients want — and it can limit your ability to grow marketing as a core part of your business.

Before Integrating, Ask:

• Will using multiple tools erode our brand experience?

• Are we giving up long-term revenue potential for short-term speed?

• Can we deliver a seamless customer journey with this setup?

Option 4: AgencyEngine — Our Solution To The Market

This is where we come in. AgencyEngine is specifically designed for BPMs that want to offer full-service digital marketing without the huge investment and complexity of building, buying and integrating multiple tools.

Think of it as the iPhone moment for BPMs - when everything finally comes together in a single, seamless platform that's dramatically more efficient, scalable and user-friendly than the fragmented tools that came before.

With AgencyEngine, you can launch white-labelled marketing services - under your brand - in less than a month. That means: 

 → No development headaches

 → No large upfront investments 

 → No patchwork of third-party tools

→ Just a fully branded marketing offering that's ready to generate revenue almost immediately.

Why AgencyEngine Stands Out:

So, why choose AgencyEngine over building, buying, or integrating? Because we’ve designed our solution specifically for BPMs, CRM providers, and platform companies that want to offer powerful digital marketing services, without the typical cost, complexity, or compromise.

Here’s what makes us different:

•  Lightning-fast go-to-market (launch in weeks, not years): Speed matters. Instead of spending 12–24 months building something from scratch, you can start offering fully branded marketing services in a matter of weeks. That means faster revenue generation, quicker client adoption, and a major competitive edge.

• Cost-effective (fraction of the price of building or buying): AgencyEngine eliminates the need for large upfront investments in tech, talent, or tools. You get enterprise-level marketing capabilities without blowing your budget, freeing up resources to invest in your core product and growth strategy.

• Seamless brand integration (clients never see us, only you): Your brand stays front and centre. Everything is white-labeled, so your clients see a consistent, professional experience that builds trust and loyalty.

• Scalable revenue opportunity with minimal risk: You can start small, scale fast, and grow your marketing services as demand increases (without hiring an in-house team or building new infrastructure). That means higher margins and predictable recurring revenue, without the operational complexity.

There is one caveat: demand is high, and AgencyEngine only works with a limited number of partners at a time. If this sounds like the right path for your business, it’s worth securing your spot early.



Ready to Elevate Your CRM Experience?

Discover how AgencyEngine combines AI website builder technology, marketing automation, and local SEO capabilities into one integrated marketing platform.